The Goal of Our Instruction–What it means to be a Professor
The T-Shirt you see above has been appearing all over Facebook of late, as if it conveyed some self-evident and profound message. Instead, I find it contrary to every value a professor ought to profess. Why not rather tell your students to assume you are wrong unless and until you make a solid case that you are right? Why not tell them to search the Scriptures daily to see if you are right or not? If your professor wears this shirt, run, do not walk, to Drop-Add, and save yourself a wasted semester.
Are we professors there in the classroom to teach our students what to think, or how to think? I certainly have some ideas that I think are true and important, and I hope that my students adopt them. But unless I teach them how to think, how to know when to swallow something and when not to, it won’t really matter whether they swallow my ideas or not. They would only last until the next authoritative pontificator contradicts them anyway.
What to think or how? You cannot do the former profitably until you have done the latter. And you can’t do the latter if your students are not encouraged to question–even to question you. They need to learn to do it courteously and respectfully, but they need to know they are encouraged to do it.
“Now these [the members of the Jewish synagogue at Berea] were more noble-minded than those in Thessalonica, for they received the word with great eagerness, searching the Scripures daily to see whether these things were so” (Acts 17:11).
Let’s raise up more noble Bereans!
Dr. Williams hopes his books are good models of how to think as well as what to think. Order them at the Lantern Hollow Press estore!
Posted on August 26, 2014, in Donald Williams, Educational Resources, Philosophy, Teaching and tagged Berea, Bereans, C. S. Lewis, critical thinking, Francis Schaeffer, pedagogy, teaching. Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.